Image

Petrolia council may ease pool fencing rules

June 2, 2017

Most Petrolia councillors think the town’s pool fencing bylaw is too restrictive, but they can’t agree yet on how to change it.
Since 2009, the town has required all pools to have four sided fences – even if one of the sides mirrored the wall of a house. The council of the day wanted to make sure someone inside wouldn’t open a door and go into a pool when there was no one watching.
In April, Petrolia resident Wade Deighton told council he didn’t think a four-sided fence was necessary if a homeowner used the side of their house as one side. He suggested other safety features on the home’s door could be used, eliminating the extra fencing.
In a report to council, Petrolia North Enniskillen Fire Chief Lawrence Swift said many other municipalities are following Petrolia’s lead of the four sided pool fence adding it is now becoming an industry standard. The town’s insurance company questioned why the town would change the standard adding “We are not lawyers but I would think that perhaps a judge might rule against the town if you were to amend the bylaw and then an incident occurred causing bodily injury.”
But several councillors felt the bylaw is too restrictive.”Homeowners feel they don’t have control of their own homes because they are being so over regulated,” Councillor Ross O’Hara told council May 23. “What’s the next thing; you can’t have a bath tub in your home because someone might drown?”
Councillor Grant Purdy, a paramedic who has been on the scene of four pool deaths, says the biggest problem is parents who aren’t watching their kids, not fencing.
“Forty-six percent of drowning are in lakes, 12 percent in bath tubs and swimming pools is 10 percent,” he says adding in most cases “supervision is present but distracted.”
But Councillors Mary Pat Gleeson and Joel Field worried about the repercussions of changing the bylaw. “If I had to choose a backyard paradise over the child’s life, I’d choose the child’s life,” says Field.
“Part of my responsibility is to make sure our citizens are safe and particularly our children,” says Gleeson defending the current bylaw. “If there is the slightest possibility a child will go through a backyard, I can’t do it.”
But in the end, Mayor John McCharles agreed the current bylaw was too restrictive and people should have a choice.
“We can try to over-save people from danger,” he says adding when he put in a pool he had the extra fencing for safety reasons.
“It is another safety factor – but that would be a choice I would like to make myself.”
However, when Purdy suggested the town require alarms on the doors of the home, McCharles voted against the motion saying he didn’t believe that would be enough protection.
“Someone has to be available for the alarm to be heard.”
So for now, the bylaw remains as it is. Town staff will research alternatives to fencing and alarms and report back to council.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Pinsonneault ‘disappointed’ Ford government reneges of promise of EA for Dresden dump

April 20, 2025

Province “must ensure we have the tools and resources to respond to any unpredictable decisions” from Trump, MPP adds Heather Wright/The Independent Lambton-Kent-Middlesex MPP Steve Pinsonneault says he’s disappointed the province won’t require the York1 project at the Dresden dump to undergo a full Environmental Assessment. But he seems to be supporting the Ford government’s move, saying “we must ensure

Read More

Image
Front Page

Lamore campaigning for the second time in 2025

April 20, 2025

Blake Ellis/The Independent This is the second time in two months Mark Lamore is on the campaign trail. He ran for the Ontario Party in the Feb.28 provincial election and now is running for the Christian Heritage Party in Sarnia-Lambton-Bkejwanong in the current federal election campaign. The vote will be exactly 60 days later; April 28. Lamore actually had no

Read More

Image
Front Page

PPC’s Everaert runs for a third time saying things haven’t changed for the better

April 20, 2025

Blake Ellis/The Independent “Things haven’t changed for the better in Canada.” That’s why Brian Everaert is once again running for the People’s Party of Canada in Sarnia-Lambton-Bkejwanong. “We want Canadians to come first all of the time.” Everaert is a founding member of the party which sprang to life in 2018 under the leadership of Maxime Bernier. He ran in

Read More

Image
Front Page

NDP’s Chan hoping to make change from the inside

April 20, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent Lo-Anne Chan says her experiences as an immigrant, a student of criminology and psychology, anentrepreneur and a mom have shaped her to meet people with compassion. And she thinks that may just be the thing voters in Sarnia-Lambton-Bkejwanong may be looking forApril 28 when they vote for their MP. Chan became the candidate for the New Democrats

Read More