Image

Stats Can wants $10k to look at raw data from Health Canada wind turbine study

December 24, 2014

 

 

A Plympton-Wyoming family trying to stop Suncor Energy from building industrial turbines will have to shell out $10,000 to look at data they think will help prove turbines hurt human health.

Lawyers for the Bryce family have asked the Environmental Review Tribunal to adjourn the hearing into the appeal of the project for six months so they can study data collected by Health Canada.

The federal agency recently released the preliminary report and the family’s lawyer believes there is evidence that can link some of the noise caused by industrial wind turbines to problems such as headaches and sleeplessness.

But Asha James told the ERT Stats Canada will only allow a researcher 22 days to analyse the data for $10,000.

Lawyers for Suncor also told the ERT adjudicators they had applied to see the raw data as well but had been told it would cost $4,500.

Elizabeth Bellavance speaks for We’re Against Industrial Turbines Plympton-Wyoming. She’s disappointed by the revelation, but not surprised.

“It’s unreasonable and is not common sense,” says Bellavance, noting Canadian taxpayers already paid $2.1 million for the study.

“It is one more added injustice to fairness,” says Bellavance.

“I’m getting to the point where I accept the unfairness, deal with it and move forward.”

But she’d like to see Suncor agree to a delay to allow researchers to look at the data.

“Why would they not want more information to support their safety values?” she asks, noting the study summary does talk about how wind turbines are “statistically associated” with health effects.

“An unbiased expert needs to access this data and review it,” says Bellavance.

While she believes the fee is unfair, for the Bryce family it is a heavy financial burden to bear, Bellavance says.

“I am hopeful the community will realize just how unfair the process is and come forward to help pay for this.”

 

 

Share This

Image
Front Page

More Lambton families face homelessness

October 22, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent Lambton County officials say more families are facing homelessness because of unemployment and the rising cost of living. “They simply can’t afford a place to live,” says Melissa Fitzpatrick, general manager of social services in Lambton County. Sarnia-Lambton’s jobless rate was 9.9 per cent in July – the last time local statistics were available from Statistics Canada,

Read More

Image
Front Page

Petrolia gives green light to online voting contract

October 21, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent Petrolia has given the green light to an electronic voting contract for the 2026 municipal election. Council approved a contract with Simply Voting Oct. 14 In a report to council, Mandi Pearson, clerk and director of legal services, said the town partnered with the City of Sarnia and nine other Lambton municipalities to search for a company

Read More

Image
Front Page

Petrolia marks waterline construction which will open up southeast end to development

October 21, 2025

Blake Ellis/The Independent “It is an exciting time for the Town of Petrolia,” said Deputy Mayor Joel Field. Friday, government officials gathered across from the work taking place on Petrolia Line in Petrolia that will upsize the water main from 200 millimetres to 300 millimetres extending from the east side of Bear Creek to Oil Heritage Road, then turn south

Read More

Image
Front Page

LCCVI juniors fall in LKSSAA soccer semifinals

October 21, 2025

John Wright/The Independent LCCVI’s junior soccer teams seasons have come to an end after a pair of semi-final losses Tuesday. Northern Collegiate got the best of LCCVI’s girls team 5-0 in Petrolia. The squads split two regular season match ups including a 4-3 win by LCCVI on Oct. 14 that gave the Lancers home field advantage in the semi-final. On

Read More