Image

OPP believe Karen Caughlin was hit by a car

December 14, 2017

Lambton OPP believe 14 year-old Karen Cauglin was hit by a car on Oil Heritage Road.

For 43 years, the Sarnia teen’s death has been investigated as a murder.

Karen and her friends were at the Rose Gardens Roller Rink March 15, 1974. She was going to stay at friend and was dropped off at the friend’s Brock Street home but never went in. Her body was found March 16 on Plowing Match Road. For years, the family has pressed the OPP to find out what happened, believing Caughlin had been murdered

Det. Insp. Chris Avery, who is the Lambton OPP detachment commander and who heads up the cold case, told reporters Thursday morning says using modern technology, and reviewing the autopsy, police have found her injuries are consistent with being struck by a car. Avery says she was likely struck on Oil Heritage Road near Lasalle. Police found her purse there at the time.

Avery says its not clear whether Caughlin was still alive when someone moved her to Plowing Match Road where she was later found.

Avery is appealing to anyone who has any information to call OPP. Police are particularly hoping to hear from people who were teens at the time who may have heard about a “social gathering” in Petrolia.

For more details on this story, pick up the Dec. 21 issue of The Independent.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Three in the running for Lambton County warden

November 19, 2026

Cathy Dobson & Heather Wright/The Independent Enniskillen Mayor Kevin Marriott wants to lead Lambton County for another two years. But there are two others who are also seeking the warden’s chair, St. Clair Township Mayor Jeff Agar and Sarnia City/County Councillor Brian White. Marriott has been Lambton County’s warden for six years. He tells The Independent he was asked by

Read More

Image
Front Page

Three charged after Point Edward break-in

November 19, 2026

The Independent Three people are facing charges after a break and enter on Marina Road in Point Edward. Monday, just before 2:30 am, police were called to the business and found three people in the fenced perimeter. They were arrested. On November 16, 2026, shortly before 2:30 a.m. members of the Lambton County Detachment of the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP)

Read More

Image
Front Page

Flyers fighting a three game losing skid

November 19, 2026

Barry Wright/The Independent Three unanswered goals in the second period was too much to overcome for the Petrolia Flyers in a 6-5 loss to the Port Stanley Sailors in PJHL action at Greenwood. After the teams played to a two-all tie at the 20-minute mark, the visitors open up a 5-2 advantage after two periods. Petrolia rallied to cut the

Read More

Image
Front Page

Flags put up five goals in one frame against Wild

November 19, 2026

Barry Wright/The Independent A five-goal second period propelled the Mooretown Flags to a 7-2 win over the Walpole Island Wild Saturday. Mooretown is now 9-10-2 on the season. Mitchell Stack led the Flags with a pair of goals and an assist and Wes Robertson had a goal and three assists. Will Harding had a goal and two helpers for Mooretown

Read More