Image

Petrolia councillor tailed by police unlikely to face Integrity Commissioner probe

December 8, 2021

Marty Souch wanted mayor to find out why staff called OPP

Heather Wright
The Independent

One August day this summer, Petrolia Councillor Marty Souch walked into the offices of The Independent to talk. He was angry.

Souch had recently talked to a Lambton OPP detective who had been tasked with shadowing him for 20 days.

A staff member had reported seeing a white van watching summer students work at Bridgeview Park and taking pictures. A senior manager, who had been told of the concern but wasn’t the summer student’s supervisor, took the matter to police suggesting Souch was involved.

Souch told The Independent at the time, the detective said it was clear he was doing nothing wrong and that he “was pretty boring” to follow around asking “what do you do all day?”

The councillor spent an hour answering questions at The Independent that day but ultimately didn’t want to talk publicly about the investigation – at least not yet.

Souch was taking the matter to Mayor Brad Loosley and expected a fiery in camera meeting to talk about the OPP investigation. Souch wanted to know “what the hell was going on?”

That private council meeting occurred Sept. 12. By November, John Fleming was investigating what was called a “staff/councillor conflict.” He released his report Nov. 25.

Souch was never named as the councillor involved.

Fleming noted the OPP found no reason to file criminal harassment charges against the councillor. The investigator felt the councillor was making sure taxpayers were getting value for their dollars.

“Perhaps appropriately, perhaps not, some take more extreme measures in their interest in cost constraint and spend more time and attention to that “watching than most would consider normal,” Fleming wrote.

The investigator hired by the town to look into the matter turned his report over to Petrolia’s Integrity Commissioner for review.

But as of now, it seems unlikely Souch will face an investigation by the Integrity Commissioner.

“There’s been no charges and there’s no investigation that I’m aware of. Now, he (the commissioner) is coming to council to do his presentation on Monday, but I’m not aware of any investigation unless I’m directed to do so,” Mayor Brad Loosley told The Independent Dec. 7.

The last time the Integrity Commissioner was called in to deal with a politician who had breached the Petrolia’s Code of Conduct, council voted to launch the investigation. Loosley says in this instance, that hasn’t happened.

And the mayor defended the town’s decision to withhold the name of the councillor who was the subject of the police investigation. Loosley says the town was advised by a lawyer not to name him, even though any councillor investigated for breaches of the Code of Conduct is named – whether guilty or not – in the name of public accountability.

“That’s certainly a valid point,” the mayor agreed when asked why taxpayers wouldn’t be able to hold the councillor accountable. “We’re going also by our information given to us. And my understanding is we are not to release that name. So, if it goes to the Integrity Commissioner, then yes, everything will be released.”

Loosley added the report showed “There was no proof of a councillor, at this time, doing that. So there were no charges laid… it was only an allegation.”

The summary of the report released publicly did not go into depth about the allegation – including how many times staff complained about a town councillor observing them – but it does mention there had been discussions about the councillor’s tactics in the past. The report notes that had been dealt with by council.

“There may have been repetition in the past, but in this report, there was no fault in this situation at all.”

Sources tell The Independent the police investigation not only cleared Souch of being involved, the person taking photos in the white van, which ultimately sparked a town employee to consult police, was a woman.

What concerned Fleming was the actions of the senior manager who went to the OPP without letting the CAO, Rick Charlebois, deal with the issue. “The OPP became involved ahead of any reference to or knowledge of the CAO,” says Fleming.

Loosley believes the Fleming investigation focuses rightly on the actions of town staff.

“The process kind of went over the CAOs head and stated how they (directors) went directly to the police, that that’s a major issue from where I stand,” he tells The Independent. “There’s processes for everything, as you know, in most municipalities that have to be followed. So, the report said these were overlooked.”

Loosley, nor Charlebois have commented if disciplinary action has been taken against staff members involved in the incident. Instead, the news release issued at the same time as the Fleming report talked about how employees have been specifically instructed on how and when the OPP should be called in for a workplace safety issue.

“The system has been fixed, the system has been corrected. And that’s why in the report it talks about it being an education for everyone. It’s been an education for some of the staff as well. But as far as any concern at this time about a councillor following, in this situation, that is not the issue at all.”

In fact, Loosley agreed almost any member of council could be following a town vehicle at any given time.

“It’s a small town,” he says. “I pull out on Eureka Street, I’m following a town truck and down the main street. I’m not following the pickup – it’s just there in the traffic….that’s going to happen. I agree with that. I think there’s that, that’s the difference… you can do that – bumping into municipal staff, councillors would happen all the time.

“And that’s why you (staff) have to fill out the necessary forms and go through the proper process.”

Monday, the town’s Integrity Commissioner will speak to council about the proper way for councillors to approach problems, including they should never give direction to staff since that’s the CAO’s job. That virtual meeting is public and will be held at 5 pm.

The Independent approached Souch this week about the original police investigation and the report by John Fleming, however he did not want to speak publicly at this time, out of concern he might break the confidentiality rules councillors must follow when an issue is dealt with during an in camera (private) meeting.

He did say he was consulting a lawyer.

Share This

Image
Front Page

LCCVI artists win at Fast Forward exhibit

May 12, 2025

Blake Ellis/The Independent “This means so much to me,” said Brooklyn Brown. The Grade 12 student at LCCVI received one of three outstanding works awards. Brown, 18, received the award which came with a $250 prize, on Saturday during the exhibition of Lambton County secondary schools’ senior student art show, Fast Forward, hosted by Gallery in the Grove in Brights

Read More

Image
Front Page

Environmental law association says Dresden dump project ‘may not be subject to any environmental assessment requirements’

May 12, 2025

The Independent The Canadian Environmental Law Association is concerned there may be no environmental oversight York1 Environmental’s plan to revive the Dresden dump. The company’s plan for a construction waste and soil recycling facility and rebuilding an expanded landfill at the site between Dresden and Dawn-Euphemia became public in last year. York1 wanted to move the massive project through the

Read More

Image
Front Page

Port Lambton Pirates sweep Chatham

May 12, 2025

Both Port Lambton teams topped the Chatham Diamonds on Saturday at the Western Counties Senior baseball season opened in Wallaceburg. The Pirates’ 22u team downed the Diamonds, 11-0 and the Port Lambton senior club beat Chatham, 12-2. Chatham fell to 0-3 on Sunday bowing 9-0 to Dresden. The scheduled game last Friday between the Wyoming Cattlebarons and the Wyoming Jr.

Read More

Image
Front Page

OPP launch school bus safety blitz after nine collisions last month

May 12, 2025

If you see an OPP cruiser following a school bus around, don’t be surprised. The OPP in southwestern Ontario has launched a campaign called Safety Stops Here this week. Officers from 13 detachments will conduct enforcement blitzes for school bus runs using marked and unmarked cruisers. Officers will also adopt a bus by selecting a route and following the bus

Read More