Image

‘Time goes on but our heart still aches’

March 16, 2024

Caughlin family marks 50 years since Karen was killed

The family of Karen Caughlin are marking a grim day – 50 years since their sister was killed; 50 years without knowing who killed her.

On March 16, 1974, the 14 year-old Sarnia girl went roller skating with friends at the Rose Gardens. She never returned home.

Her battered body was discovered the following morning on Plowing Match Road between Churchill Line and Lasalle Line north of Petrolia. No one has ever been arrested.

For years, family members begged for the OPP to find the person who killed their sister, however police didn’t make any headway on Caughlin’s death.

For 43 years, Lambton OPP said Caughlin had been murdered.

Then, in 2017, the OPP said new information revealed that Karen’s injuries were consistent with being struck by a motor vehicle. Police said during a news conference they believed Caughlin had been struck by a car on Oil Heritage Road near Lasalle Line – her purse was found nearby – and then was then moved to where her body was found. Police said at the time it was not clear whether the teen would have still been alive when she was moved.

OPP in 1974 on Plowing Match Road where Karen Caughlin’s body was found. OPP Image

Family members to this day say Karen’s death was murder. In a social media post Saturday, Caughlin’s sister, Kathy, said “Today marks the painful 50th anniversary without you Karen. When a lonely country road became a grave site, and the road still holds the dark secrets of your murder.

Caughlin added “time goes on but our hearts still ache, and the tears still flow…Still loved, still missed in every way.”

Lambton OPP also issued a news release on the 50th anniversary of Karen Caughlin’s death saying they continue to investigate and follow up on tips. “Police want to hear from or about anyone who may have discussed attending or hosting a social gathering in Petrolia after going to the Rose Gardens roller skating rink, perhaps the day before Karen was last seen alive,” officials said in a news release.

“The OPP also wants to hear from anyone with information about a motor vehicle collision in the Petrolia area, or damage sustained by a motor vehicle around that time. Someone may have observed damage to a vehicle or not noticed damage to their own vehicle at the time.”

There is still a $50,000 reward for information about the teen’s death.

Share This

Image
Front Page

WM, Ontario Premier officially opens natural gas plant in Watford

November 12, 2026

The Independent WM officially opened its $150 million renewable natural gas plant and pipeline Thursday. The methane produced at Twin Creeks – one of the largest in Ontario – already powers a nearby greenhouse complex. But only 40 per cent of what is produced by the 1.4 million tonnes of waste hauled to the site yearly is used at the

Read More

Image
Front Page

LCCVI students held at school as OPP investigated weapons sighting

November 12, 2026

The Independent A few tense moments at LCCVI this afternoon. Students were held at the school until after the normal end of their day after the Lambton-Kent District School Board had students and staff in a “hold and secure” state as a safety measure. LKDSB Public Relations Officer Caress Lee says the school was alerted to an incident at the

Read More

Image
Front Page

North Lambton claims third consecutive Lambton-Kent Sr. Girls basketball title

November 12, 2026

John Wright/The Independent North Lambton came away with a 42-41 win after a back and forth battle with LCCVI in the LKSSAA Senior Girls ‘AA’ basketball final Thursday night in Petrolia. The Eagles started fast, jumping out to a 24-7 lead but the Lancers fought all the way back to take a two-point lead at the end of three quarters.

Read More

Image
Front Page

Sting trade former top pick Lammens to Owen Sound

November 12, 2026

Barry Wright/The Independent A much rumoured deal involving Brenner Lammens is now a reality. The former fourth overall pick in the 2025 OHL Priority Selection has been dealt to the Owen Sound Attack for veteran centre Jake Crawford and draft picks. Lammens and a 15th round conditional pick in 2030 goes north. The late round conditional draft choice moves up

Read More