Image

OPP urge people to come forward as another year passes after the death of Karen Caughlin

March 17, 2025

Another year has passed without answers in the death of Karen Caughlin.

Fifty-one years ago, the 14 year-old went to the Rose Garden to go rollerskating with friends. She was last seen being dropped off near a friend’s home in Sarnia Saturday, March 16, 1974.

Karen Caughlin

Her body was discovered the next morning near Marthaville, on Plowing Match Road between Churchill and Lasalle Line.

Lambton OPP reminded the public of Caughlin’s death hoping to spur new information in the investigation to identify the people responsible.

In 2017, police said they believed the teen had been hit by a vehicle and her body was moved from the location on Oil Heritage Line to Plowing Match Road. For decades, her death had been treated as a homicide and the family of the teen still believe what happened was a murder.

OPP officials say they’re still investigating every tip which comes to light and a $50,000 reward is still available for clues leading to the people responsible for her death. The department’s case chronology video has been viewed over 35,000 times.

Police want to hear from or about anyone who may have discussed attending or hosting a social gathering in Petrolia after going to the Rose Gardens roller skating rink the day before Karen was last seen alive. The OPP also wants to hear from anyone with information about a motor vehicle collision in the Petrolia area, or damage sustained by a motor vehicle around that time.

If you have any information you can call police at 1-888-310-1122 or Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS (8477) to remain anonymous.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Heat warning issued for Wednesday and Thursday

June 10, 2026

FROM LAMBTON PUBLIC HEALTH With the prediction of hot and humid weather expected for Wednesday, June 10through Thursday, June 11, Environment and Climate Change Canada is issuing a Heat Warning forLambton County. Heat warnings are issued when two or more consecutive days of daytime maximum temperatures areexpected to reach 31°C or warmer and nighttime minimum temperatures are expected to sit

Read More

Image
Front Page

MP calls out OPP after doxxing incidents

June 10, 2026

Heather Wright/The Independent Sarnia-Lambton-Bkejwanong MP Marilyn Gladu is calling out the OPP after failing to charge a man who released her home address online. Gladu has been subject to public ridicule and harassment online, attacks at her Sarnia constituency office and threats to her staff as well as personal death threat after the long-time Conservative MP decided to join the

Read More

Image
Front Page

Sarnia interim police chief on the job

June 10, 2026

The Independent Sarnia’s interim police chief is on the job. Police Services Board Chair Kelly Ash says Mike Federico was sworn in Monday, the same day Deputy Chief Ron Hansen and a civilian were suspended. The two suspensions are linked to the workplace harassment investigation lodged against Chief Derek Davis May 19. Eight days later, after the board reviewed the

Read More

Image
Front Page

Co-founder of Lambton Concert Band retires

June 9, 2026

Blake Ellis/The Independent For 82 years, Norm Sutherland has immersed himself in his passion of playing music and performing with various bands. May 24, the 92 year-old Petrolia man gave his last performance with the Bluewater Wind Ensemble, a group he has been playing with for the past two years. Sutherland joined Petrolia’s White Rose Junior Band at the age

Read More