March 13, 2014

Just days from the 40th anniversary of her murder, the OPP will be releasing a new video hoping to spark memories about the slaying of Karen Caughlin.

But for the family, March 15 is significant only because it marks 40 years of hell.

Karen Caughlin was just 14 when the Sarnia girl went roller-skating with her friends at the Rose Garden on March 15, 1974. She never returned home. Her battered body was found on Plowing Match Road outside of Police have never charged anyone in her murder.

More than a decade ago, the OPP began actively investigating the cold case, while her sisters, Kathy Caughlin and Mary Lou Schwemler anxiously waited. But they soon became disillusioned with the investigation, charging the OPP had mishandled the case. In May 2011, the family held a news conference calling for an external review of the file.

Caughlin’s concerns were renewed when two local car collectors said a 1970 Plymouth Road Runner with chips of Plum Crazy paint matching the description of one involved in Karen’s death was never examined, despite several calls to the OPP. That prompted a protest in front of the Lambton OPP station last August, but still no resolution.

Months later, the family said it would no longer deal with the OPP saying the believed the case should be reviewed by an outside police agency. The OPP steadfastly maintained they continued to actively investigate the case.

Thursday, (March 13) the OPP will unveil a video reconstructing the last hours of Karen’s life hoping to jar 40 year old memories.

Schwemler has been in contact with the OPP and knows about the video. She hopes it will help, but Schwemler isn’t sure it will.

“My family has lived in hell for 40 years. I still hold on to the hope that the OPP will agree to an independent review one day, but I am not holding my breath,” Schwemler wrote to The Independent via Facebook.

“We have lived with their lies for too long and finally we are walking away from the OPP. Karen will always be with us and we hope and pray that someday we will all have peace in our hearts.

“Living 40 years without my sister Karen causes an indescribable pain in my heart every day.  Dealing with the OPP only adds to the pain. It is hard to deal with people that you no longer trust.”

And while the OPP again remind people of Karen’s murder on the anniversary of her death, Schwemler says she is remembering her beautiful sister. “Karen is always with me, everyday.”

 

 

Share This

Image
Front Page

Two Ontario men face charges after alleged immigration fraud at Lambton College

July 10, 2026

Heather Wright/The Independent EDITOR’S NOTE: This story was edited July 10 to include comments from the College of Immigration and Citizenship Consultants Two men are facing immigration and criminal charges after Lambton College tipped authorities off about a student immigration scam. College officials called the Canada Border Services Agency in February 2025, about students who had dealt with immigration consultants.

Read More

Image
Front Page

OPP look for missing Crime Stoppers sign in Thedford

July 9, 2026

The Independent It may not be a good sign for Crime Stoppers. Lambton OPP were called to the intersection of Highway 70 and Arkona Road after a large Crime Stoppers sign at the entrance of the community was stolen. It’s valued at $800. Police are investigating, adding if you have tip about the stolen Crime Stoppers’ sign, you can call

Read More

Image
Front Page

Whoops: Local plowing match officials back track, confirms Brigden will host 2027 IPM after all

July 9, 2026

Heather Wright/The Independent The Lambton 2027 International Plowing Match Committee says they were wrong; the 2027 event will be in Brigden. A local committee landed the International Plowing Match and Rural Expo in April 2025. The group attracted hundreds of volunteers and planning was well underway. In late May, Ontario Plowmen’s Association (OPA) officials came to Brigden, working with the

Read More

Image
Front Page

Integrity Commissioner dismisses complaint against Dennis’ ‘woke’ art tirade

July 9, 2026

The Independent The Integrity Commissioner says a Sarnia councillor’s comments about an Indigenous mural at City Hall were “a political argument” and has dismissed the complaint. In March, Sarnia unveiled a mural depicting the relationship between Sarnia-Lambton and The Council of Three Fires Confederacy; the Ojibway, Odawa, and Potawatomi people. The project included the $5,000 mural, a new wall honouring

Read More