Image

Firefighters’ lawyer believes careless driving prosecution abuse; filing Charter claim

May 27, 2015

A Wyoming firefighter charged after an accident in a snowstorm on the 402 will go to trial while his lawyer claim abuse of the court process.

And several professional associations are offering to help him beat the charge.

Last March, Neil Bain was driving one of two fire trucks on the way to an accident on the highway in the middle of a snowstorm. The firefighters were doing an estimated 40 km per hour in the blinding snow when they were caught up in a multi-vehicle collision.

Bain’s wrist was broken and four other firefighters were injured in the crash.

Bain was charged with careless driving in the accident. That charge was met with anger with the Fire Chief suggesting the charge was politically motivated. Local politicians had been voicing concern about the maintenance along the stretch of highway after a number of multi-vehicle crashes.

Mike Vasey and several associations representing volunteer firefighters also voiced concern about the precedent being set by charging a volunteer while on duty.

The crown and Bain’s lawyer, Ian Bruce, met with the judge for about 40-minutes. Firefighters and Bain were hopeful the charge would be thrown out for lack of evidence. But that wasn’t to be.

Bain, surrounded by about 15 firefighters in uniform and family members, looked shocked when he heard a trial would start Nov. 23.

Bain’s lawyer hasn’t given up on having the charges dropped. He told the judge he would be filing a challenge under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms claiming abuse of the court process.

“Anyone who analyses the facts would say the facts do not support a conviction,” Bruce told The Independent. “There is a strong likelihood the charge will be dismissed, whether that happens after a trial or before remains to be seen.

“We’re asking the court to apply common sense. They know all the evidence. They know there is not going to be a conviction, why go through that process?”

Fire Chief Mike Vasey, who was in court supporting Bain, says the news is disappointing.

“This has been an extreme hardship on the family,” he says noting no other driver was charged in the pile up and another driver who ran into a police cruiser was not charged.

“They stay at home and don’t go out; they don’t go for dinner anymore because it is all people want to talk about,” says Vasey. “Everyone is very supportive…but everyday, you can’t get away from it.”

Vasey says both the Firefighters’ Association of Ontario and the Ontario Fire Chiefs’ Association have expressed a willingness to help with the legal battle. “They want to put their legal teams on it and help out anyway they can because of the huge ramifications of this across the province,” he says.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Plans for Camlachie mini arena shelved

April 24, 2025

The project’s drivers – the Huron Shores Optimists – say it would place a financial burden on the club Heather Wright/The Independent The Huron Shores Optimist and the Town of Plympton-Wyoming say they will be working together on a recreation project in Camlachie, but it won’t be the $2.3 million outdoor arena project. The Optimist floated the idea of an

Read More

Image
Front Page

Petrolia, WM give out $15K in green grants

April 23, 2025

There will be more trails, trees and environmentally-friendly lighting thanks to the Town of Petrolia and WM’s Green Grants. The town announced $15,000 in funding on Earth Day. 2025 Successful Projects: The IODE Margaret Stokes Chapter was successful in their application for Moncreif Park and JubileeTrail Revitalization in the amount of $5,000. The funds will be used to plant native

Read More

Image
Front Page

‘We will be fighting this’ bid to push through York1 plan Canniff tells province

April 23, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent When Chatham-Kent Mayor Darrin Canniff first got the call, he thought it was good news. Instead, he’s gearing up for an all-out fight to stop York1 Environmental Waste Solutions from pushing through its plans to reopen the derelict Dresden dump. Canniff got a call from the Minister of the Environment’s office Thursday around noon. When he returned

Read More

Image
Front Page

Petrolia Water intake contractor approved

April 22, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent Two major projects in Petrolia are moving forward. In 2022, the town received of a $16 million grant to replace the Lake Huron water intake pipe which was installed in 1944 and is nearing the end of its life. Monday, Petrolia council awarded the contract for the new water intake at the Brights Grove Water Treatment Plant

Read More