Image

Cause of deadly Marthaville Road fire undetermined

October 18, 2017

The cause of the fire which claimed two lives in Dawn-Euphemia will never be known.
Cindy Lou Beyea, 54, and Malcom McKinnon, 61, of Marthaville Road near Bentpath died in the fire on Jan. 29.
By the time the Dawn-Euphemia Fire Department arrived at the scene, flames could be seen shooting from the house over the top of giant cedar trees which surrounded it.
After nine months of investigation, the official cause is listed as undetermined.
Steve Martin investigated the blaze for the Ontario Fire Marshal’s Office. He says because the home is in a rural area, the fire wasn’t spotted for some time. By the time firefighters arrived, the evidence was destroyed.
Martin says normally investigators studies want to “know where it started and what was the fuel load. I couldn’t even get to that point,” he tells The Independent.
“It was a two storey home and I can’t determine which level it started on. We just can’t determine fire patterns when the fire is in such an advanced state.”
And he says there is no way to determine when the fire started either. Firefighters were called to the home in the early morning hours after neighbours spotted the flames over the treetops.
“By all accounts, it was well advanced before the fire department got there, that’s not to say they didn’t do all they could, but it was a rural property and it wasn’t discovered until later… they did the best they could.”
Martin says it is believed there was a smoke detector in the home. Fire prevention officers had been to the home just a year before the blaze and at the time the homeowner told the fire department there was a detector on site however it wasn’t found in the home.
“There was no reasonable prospect of recovering the smoke detector. It’s one of the first things that melts,” says Martin. The investigator concedes its difficult to list the cause as undetermined. “I don’t like loose ends. It’s extremely frustrating.”

Share This

Image
Front Page

Sarnia police say it’s never too late to report sexual assault

September 24, 2026

The Independent Sarnia Police are pointing to the conviction of a former Sarnia Observer sports reporter to remind victims of sexual assault it is never too late to call police. Sept. 18, Miller, who now lives in Penticton, BC, was found guilty of four counts of sexual interference and one count of invitation to sexual touching. The convictions stem from

Read More

Image
Front Page

Mural of ‘iconic Sarnia images’ on Indian Road complete

September 24, 2026

The Independent Drivers taking Indian or Plank Roads in Sarnia have something new to see – a giant mural of what Imperial Oil officials call some of the most iconic images of Sarnia-Lambton. Local artist Kennady Osborne of Seventh Rayn Design. Co created the work first on canvas. Then, the art work was transformed into a 95-foot by 30-foot mural,

Read More

Image
Front Page

Young people urged to stay involved in municipal politics

September 24, 2026

Cathy Dobson/The Independent Getting good jobs for youth and ensuring they can afford to buy a house are top priorities for numerous Sarnia council candidates hoping to be elected Oct. 26. “I’m new and I don’t have all the answers, but my fear is that I’ll have to die in order for my children to own a house and I

Read More

Image
Front Page

Dennis leaves all-candidates forum before it begins

September 23, 2026

Cathy Dobson/The Independent An abrupt departure by Bill Dennis at a youth-led all-candidates forum Wednesday means the five Sarnia mayoral candidates have not yet faced off during this municipal election campaign. Numerous people witnessed a verbal altercation between Dennis and a youth prior to the event held at the Lambton College events centre.   He left shortly after, according to Michelle

Read More