Image

Brooke-Alvinston looking into cost of taping council meetings

May 16, 2019

 

It won’t happen this year, but Brooke-Alvinston council is looking into the idea of taping council meetings.
Councillor Jamie Armstrong suggested the idea and staff looked into some of the costs and concerns with the idea.
In a report to council, Clerk-Administrator Janet Denkers says only four per cent of municipalities recorded open council meetings in 2017. Nearby Adelaide-Metcalfe is one of those. It purchased about $6,500 worth of equipment and estimates it takes about one or two hours of staff time to upload the video to a YouTube site after council meetings.
Denkers added the Town of Petrolia also looked into the idea and estimated it could cost between $11,650 and $30,000 to set up a video recording system.
Armstrong spoke in favour of the idea at Thursday’s council meeting saying it was helpful to be able to access council meetings on line in Adelaide-Metcalfe at the click of a button.
And he says a recording of a council meeting could be helpful should there be an investigation by the Integrity Commissioner into a councillor’s conduct. “With the video and an integrity commissioner’s (investigation) there won’t be so much of a he said, she said situation,” says Armstrong.
With the Integrity Commissioner charging about $280 per hour for his work, Armstrong contends it could save the taxpayers money.
The staff report also says, “being videotaped can drastically change the dynamics of a meeting including the comfort level of delegations presenting to council. All people should be comfortable with being videotaped as it can be perceived as a distraction in the council chamber,” Denkers wrote.
Councillor Frank Nemcek agreed. “I don’t feel comfortable with being taped,” he says. “People can read on the website what’s going on, they can come and see what’s happening here,” he said suggesting there was enough ways for residents to figure out what is going on at council. “I don’t feel comfortable.”
Armstrong doesn’t believe that will be a problem. “If people are aware of being taped, hopefully, they will be more respectful of proceedings.”
The report also points out the audio or video recording of municipal council meetings isn’t required under the Municipal Act.
Currently, Denkers is responsible for the official record of the council meetings. She says between three or four staff members take notes during public meetings and at least two staff members are present at in camera meetings.
She says she often checks her facts with other staff members to ensure the minutes are accurate.
In the last few months, staff has begun to post staff reports and minutes on the municipal website for residents to access.
Even if council wanted to move forward, Denkers isn’t sure it would be technically possible to upload video or audio on the current website. There is money in this budget to upgrade Brooke-Alvinston’s website.
Denkers report did note the Integrity Commissioner had suggested recording in camera meetings to be used only if there was a concern council might have discussed some matters privately, which should have been public. There was a recommendation that in camera meetings be recorded.
Instead, council agreed to have staff investigate the cost of recording meetings in Brooke-Alvinston. The results would be reviewed during 2020 budget deliberations.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Forest Kiwanis hope a mandarin, apple and cucumber can raise some cash for Kineto

February 7, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent “Why would somebody give 6.2 million for a banana on the wall?” That’s what Forest’s Jose Van Haastert thought after seeing what a crypto billionaire paid for a piece of conceptual art with a banana on the wall. Her family talked about the massive price tag for the art over Christmas. But the idea got Van Haastert,

Read More

Image
News

New scholarship program at Great Lakes created in honour of late Sarnia judge

February 7, 2025

Students in St. Clair Township and Sarnia will be able to apply for a new scholarship program, named in honour of an Ontario Court Justice from Sarnia. The Sarnia Community Foundation says the family of the late Anne McFadyen has set up an annual scholarship program, similar to LCCVI’s Nicol Scholarships. It will honour five graduating students from Great Lakes

Read More

Front Page

Driver taken to hospital after Inwood accident

February 7, 2025

An Alvinston woman had to be taken to hospital after an accident near Inwood Monday. Lambton OPP have yet to release any details about the crash Monday morning which occurred during foggy conditions. Witnesses say two vehicles, a van and large pickup truck, collided at the corner of Inwood and Shiloh Line Monday morning. The van was T-boned. Brooke-Alvinston Fire

Read More

Image
Sports

LCCVI on top of girls high school hockey standings

February 7, 2025

LCCVI moved into a first place tie with Chatham-Kent Secondary School in girls’ high school hockey this week with a 2-1 win over the Golden Hawks in Chatham. The Lancers are 2-0-2 in the south division this season. The regular season wraps up late next week. Playoff dates have yet to be announced.

Read More