Image

Sarnia man pleads guilty to killing friend after a fight over drugs

November 20, 2020

Matthew Gerard Theriault admitted to killing his friend in a drug and alcohol fueled fight.

The Sarnia man plead guilty to manslaughter Friday in the killing of Jesse Mowat-Caudle in April 2019.

The 32 year-old had been charged with second-degree murder.

Several family members of the victim were in court to watch the 15 minute guilty plea.

Theriault spoke only to answer questions from Justice Bruce Thomas, including whether he understood the charge and was willing to give up his right to a trial with the guilty plea.

The court heard there was an argument between Theriault and Mowat-Caudle over the purchase of weed at a Maxwell St. home earlier in the day. After drinking and smoking together Mowat-Caudle went outside to cool down and Theriault followed with a knife.

Theriault stabbed Mowat-Caudle twice in the driveway, causing severe injuries. Police arrived on the scene just after 4 pm and immediately arrested Theriault.

“I didn’t mean it, he attacked me,” Theriault said at the time. However a self-defense argument was not pursued by defense lawyer David Stoesser.

Mowat-Caudle was bleeding heavily and taken to hospital in London, but succumbed to his wounds just after midnight the following day. He was just 26-years-old. Mowat-Caudle’s death was Sarnia’s first homicide in three years.

Theriault will return to Superior Court for sentencing on Jan. 12, 2021.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Former Courtright haunt of Al Capone being demolished

July 24, 2026

The Independent The home of the first business in Courtright – said to be the former haunt of gangster Al Capone – is being torn down. Demolition of what once was the Cathcart General Store started July 21. Local historian Kip Cuthbert says the building dates back to around the 1850’s as a general store. “William Cathcart established his general

Read More

Image
Front Page

Four charged with drug trafficking by Anishinabek Police after stop in Lambton Shores

July 24, 2026

The Independent Four people have been arrested after a drug trafficking investigation that started in May and ended with a traffic stop in Lambton Shores July 21. Anishinabek Police Service officers stopped a vehicle in Lambton Shores July 21. Police searched the vehicle and found seven grams of fentanyl and 51 hydromorphone tables. A 57-year-old man and 43 year-old woman,

Read More

Image
Front Page

Bluewater Bridge border guards seized 1.1 tonnes of drugs in $139 million bust

July 24, 2026

Heather Wright/The Independent About 1.1 tonnes of the drugs seized in a $139 million drug investigation were seized at the Bluewater Bridge. And a Corunna man is one of 21 people charged in the massive drug ring which netted a total of 1.7 tonnes of cocaine, methamphetamine, opium and oxycodone. The investigation began in Windsor in January 2025. “At that

Read More

Image
Front Page

Ashley Norton Caught the Ace

July 24, 2026

Imperial Oil employee takes home $4.5 million in Sarnia Legion Cathy Dobson & Heather Wright/The Independent After 45 weeks, hundreds of thousands of tickets sold, food banks restocked and a whole lot of fun, the Chase for the Ace is over. Thursday, Ashley Norton’s ticket was drawn at the Sarnia Legion. The 44-year-old Imperial Oil maintenance manager chose envelope number

Read More