Image

Buurma Acres fails to recoup $125K in legal fees for farm board hearing

October 14, 2021

Lawyers said Brooke-Alvinston ‘made a clear and concerted effort to malign the character of David Buurma’

An attempt by one of the principals of Buurma Acres to force Brooke-Alvinston to pay his legal bills for a case he filed to the Normal Farm Practices Protection Board has failed.

In April 2020, David Buurma appealed to the board to look at the bylaws of Brooke-Alvinston limiting the director of Lasalle Agri from storing the fertilizer made from human waste on fields in the region and to store large quantities of it on a Buurma Acres farm on Churchill Line.

The board ruled that while centralized storage was a normal farm practice, the facility Buurma Acres was using wasn’t adequate. It ordered the organization to fix the building to reduce the possibility of odours escaping and spontaneous combustion of the material.

Recently, lawyers for Buurma filed written arguments to the board asking it to order Brooke-Alvinston to pay $125,000 of its $173,121 legal bill.

Buurma’s lawyers wrote the municipality “made a clear and concerted effort to malign
the character of David Buurma as a principal of LaSalle Agri Inc. It is alleged that this started before the hearing and came out further during the course of the hearing,” adding “there was an attempt to ‘demonize’ the fertilizer itself.”

The municipality denied that.

The NFPPB Chair, Glenn Walker wrote in his Oct. 5 decision, “there was no attempt to malign the character of David Buurma personally; and if there was, there is no evidence to suggest that this was done maliciously.”

Buurma’s lawyers also said the municipality should have paid legal costs because it failed to call evidence from anyone with farming experience, or about concerns about the environment, nor did it call expert witness about the odour concerns or first responders about the smouldering biosolids fertilizer in question.

Walker says normally, costs would be awarded if a defense wasn’t mounted at all.

“A party should be free to choose the nature and amount of evidence it calls at a hearing.
It may be that the party will be unsuccessful in the litigation as a result of that choice.
However, that choice does not represent clearly unreasonable, frivolous, vexatious or bad
faith conduct,” Walker wrote.

The chair of the NFFPB turned down Buurma’s requests for costs.

The municipality in its reply to the request asked the chair to award it costs of $11,413 for responding to Buurma’s application to have his legal fees paid. Walker instead ordered Buurma to pay $1,000 to the municipality and added in any future cases the costs would be “more realistic.”

The Independent calculated that by May 2021, Brooke-Alvinston had already spent $128,260.72 defending itself at the NFPPB. Warwick had also incurred $12,500 in costs. Brooke-Alvinston, Warwick and Dawn-Euphemia, who were all advised Buurma Acres had filed cases before the NFPPB, were to split those bills three ways once the legal proceedings were over.

Share This

Image
Front Page

ICYMI: Record-breaking crowd at Alvinston Rodeo

June 20, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent Like the movie says; if you build it, they will come. The Alvinston Pro Rodeo committee brought in larger stands hoping to accommodate visitors to the three-day event. Saturday night, those stands were filled and there were still people looking for seats according to Chairman Dan Cumming. Here’s just some of the action from the event:

Read More

Image
Front Page

Lambton Public Health issues first heat warning of the summer

June 20, 2025

FROM LAMBTON PUBLIC HEALTH With the prediction of hot and humid weather expected to start on Saturday,June 21 and continue into next week, Environment and Climate Change Canada is issuing a HeatWarning for Lambton County. Heat warnings are issued when two or more consecutive days of daytime maximum temperatures areexpected to reach 31°C or warmer and nighttime minimum temperatures are

Read More

Image
Front Page

Rural bus service starts making stops in Wyoming Monday

June 20, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent Before there was money to bring a bus into Wyoming, Susan Mills was answering questions from residents about a new rural transit system. The Town of Plympton-Wyoming became a partner in the rural transit system called Huron Shores Area Transit earlier this spring. But service didn’t begin immediately. Lambton Shores, which runs the system, and its partners,

Read More

Image
Front Page

Why spend $20K to study a bridge to nowhere: McEwen

June 20, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent Plympton-Wyoming Deputy Mayor Netty McEwen says it doesn’t make sense to spend $20,000 to study a bridge that goes nowhere. Paul daSilva, Director of Public Works, in a report to council June 11, suggested spending $40,000 to do Municipal Environmental Assessments on two low-traffic bridges, one on O’Brien Road, the other on Elmsley Road. “I took a

Read More