Image

Petrolia developer loses another bid to move ahead with Countryview housing in the woods

April 21, 2023

A Petrolia developer has lost another bid to start developing a 17 acre woodlot.

Elbee Investments wants to build 74 new homes in Countryview Estates in a woodlot on the west side of the subdivision. When the original plan was laid out in 2007, the lots were in the wooded area. But sometime between 2007 and 2021, it was rezoned a significant woodlot by the town.

In May 2021, after two contentious public meetings, town council removed the significant woodlot status, after the developer produced some environmental studies which council believe cleared the way for the development. Those studies have never been provided to the public.

While the town approved, two people, Greg Racher, whose farm abuts the land, and Petrolia resident William Loerts, appealed the ruling to the Ontario Land Tribunal, in part because they believe there is a protected tree species in the area. In July 2022, the OLT ruled more study on the land was needed including identifying natural heritage features and the impact of the development.

The OLT said an Environmental Impact Study was required by all policies of the province, Lambton County and Petrolia and the studies the developers did complete, did not address all the components of the study. Without it, the developers didn’t meet all the legislative requirements and could not move forward.

Not satisfied with the ruling, the developers – Bob Leaper and Louis Bratenek – appealed the decision to the chair of the OLT saying the tribunal made errors of law in the ruling since the town and county had approved the use of the studies.

Michael Kraljevic, in a written decision released Thursday, said Elbee’s lawyers basically seemed to be re-arguing the original case.

He said that doesn’t meet the guidelines of raising a “convincing and compelling case” for a full review. “The tribunal does not routinely review decisions,” Kraljevic writes.

The chair writes Elbee’s lawyer charged the board “erred in law in failing to defer to the decision of the town in the exercise of its discretion in applying official plan policies and determining the appropriate studies” and in ignoring the expert studies completed in support of the proposed development.”

Kraljevic notes the tribunal found all of the provincial, county and municipal planning documents showed an Environmental Impact Study was needed adding the town would be able to decide if the housing could go ahead after the Environmental Impact Study.

Kraljevic writes Elbee’s lawyers suggest that “since the county, town, St. Clair Region Conservation Authority and the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks had all determined that the necessary studies were completed, the tribunal ought to also have been satisfied.

“I disagree with this argument in the strongest terms. The purpose of the tribunal is to hear and decide appeals. To suggest the tribunal should offer complete deference to other entities disregards the scope of the tribunal’s authority and its role in the planning law regime.”

Elbee’s lawyer had not responded to questions from The Independent about what the developer will now do.

However in the judgment denying Elbee’s OLT appeal, the chair writes the developer has filed a “leave to appeal the decision” in court.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Forest Kiwanis hope a mandarin, apple and cucumber can raise some cash for Kineto

February 7, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent “Why would somebody give 6.2 million for a banana on the wall?” That’s what Forest’s Jose Van Haastert thought after seeing what a crypto billionaire paid for a piece of conceptual art with a banana on the wall. Her family talked about the massive price tag for the art over Christmas. But the idea got Van Haastert,

Read More

Image
News

New scholarship program at Great Lakes created in honour of late Sarnia judge

February 7, 2025

Students in St. Clair Township and Sarnia will be able to apply for a new scholarship program, named in honour of an Ontario Court Justice from Sarnia. The Sarnia Community Foundation says the family of the late Anne McFadyen has set up an annual scholarship program, similar to LCCVI’s Nicol Scholarships. It will honour five graduating students from Great Lakes

Read More

Front Page

Driver taken to hospital after Inwood accident

February 7, 2025

An Alvinston woman had to be taken to hospital after an accident near Inwood Monday. Lambton OPP have yet to release any details about the crash Monday morning which occurred during foggy conditions. Witnesses say two vehicles, a van and large pickup truck, collided at the corner of Inwood and Shiloh Line Monday morning. The van was T-boned. Brooke-Alvinston Fire

Read More

Image
Sports

LCCVI on top of girls high school hockey standings

February 7, 2025

LCCVI moved into a first place tie with Chatham-Kent Secondary School in girls’ high school hockey this week with a 2-1 win over the Golden Hawks in Chatham. The Lancers are 2-0-2 in the south division this season. The regular season wraps up late next week. Playoff dates have yet to be announced.

Read More