Image

BREAKING: Wyoming firefighter dismissal was sparked by abuse investigation say lawyers

June 17, 2020

There are new details coming to light of what led to the dismissal of three Wyoming firefighters.

In February, three veteran firefighters, Lt. Carrie Ann Wilson, Sr. Firefighter Jason Lyon and District Chief Jeff Scott were dismissed after an investigations into allegations of physical and verbal abuse of Wilson at the scene of an incident.

In an news release issued today, the trio’s lawyers say they are ready to talk about the dismissal. They say it was a case of wrongful dismissal.

The lawyers, Matthew Chapman and William Fawcett say in August, Wilson was physically assaulted by another firefighter who the lawyers name as Pete Moraal. Wilson alleges Moraal shoved her out of the way at the scene of an incident with his shoulder after a verbal disagreement.

Chapman and Fawcett says Wilson was also verbally assaulted at the scene of a fire in September – car had fled into a farmers field and one of the stations pumpers slipped into a creek after a soft bank gave way.

“During the verbal assault, Lieutenant Moraal had to be physically restrained by other firefighters. Lieutenant Wilson, who is the only female firefighter to have served in the history of the department and who had been promoted to the rank of lieutenant less than three years after joining the fire service, was the Incident Commander for both incident responses when the abuse by Lieutenant Moraal occurred,” the lawyers alleges in the news release.

Wilson chose not to file a complaint after being physically assaulted for fear of reprisal.

The two incidents came to light in December at an officers meeting and an investigation started.

Darcy Michaud of HRprimed was the investigator. The lawyers say he had “an appearance of being coopted toward scrutinizing members of the fire department who had clashed with Chief Steve Clemens since his hiring in late 2016.”

Fawcett and Chapman say the three were dismissed the day before the investigators report was given to council.

Three other firefighters resigned after they were reprimanded after the investigation – including Capt. Mike McGrail, who brought the incidents to light.

The lawyers say all six involved had challenged the chief in the past, and say Wilson was the firefighter who discovered a webcam in the department in 2017.

Clemens had been placed on leave in June 2017 while a lawyer hired by the town investigated. Clemens was cleared of any wrong doing. Fawcett says all those who were dismissed or reprimanded had challenged Chief Clemens in the past.

“There is a long standing conflict between Chief Clemens with a number of the people in the fire department; Carrie Ann and Jason are among them,” says Fawcett.

Since the February dismissals, 15 firefighters have left the Wyoming department.

Lawyers say in March, 27 members of the service submitted a letter to Mayor Lonny Napper and council raising concerns about Clemens’ leadership, the poisonous environment created in the department and their concerns the fire department would not be able to function well in the current situation.

That letter has never been dealt with publicly.

Fawcett says there no wrongful dismissal claim filed but it is pending.

The Independent did request a statement from the Town of Plympton-Wyoming. CAO Carolyn Tripp says the town doesn’t comment on Human Resource issues.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Sarnia all-candidates debate a revealing evening

October 21, 2026

Cathy Dobson/The Independent With less than a week until election day, 28 candidates vying for eight council seats, spent four hours Tuesday trying to stand out as the right choice for Sarnia voters. They gathered at The Imperial Theatre in front of an audience of 200, with another 500 streaming the marathon event online. Compared to Monday night’s mayoral debate,

Read More

Image
Front Page

St. Clair will be reimbursed for help at Chatham ethanol plant fire

October 21, 2026

Heather Wright/The Independent St. Clair Township Councillor Brad Langstaff wants to know what it cost for the fire department to help fight an ethanol plant fire in Chatham. Sept. 16, 15 firefighters, the township’s two tower trucks and its drone headed to Chatham to help battle a massive fire at Greenfield Global. St. Clair was called on because it has

Read More

Image
Front Page

Enniskillen rejects request for ATVs on township roads

October 21, 2026

Blake Ellis/The Independent ATVs won’t be allowed on Enniskillen roads. A request by Enniskillen Resident Mark Braet failed to sway Enniskillen Township Council to allow all terrain vehicles on township roads. Braet made a presentation to council on Oct. 8 along with representatives from the Tri-Shore ATV Club. Braet wanted to be allowed to drive ATVs on roads in the

Read More

Image
Front Page

LAMBTON VOTES: Petrolia Candidate Surveys

October 21, 2026

The Independent sent a questionnaire to each candidate for Petrolia Council. Below are the unedited responses from the candidates: Work Experience: Policy Advisor, Sarnia-Lambton Chamber of Commerce; former Constituency Assistant to MPPs Bob Bailey and Billy Pang; former parliamentary intern with MPs Marilyn Gladu and Jake Stewart; former Town of Petrolia Parks & Recreation Summer Labourer; former Dietary Aide at

Read More