Image

Councillors, Alvinston Optimist under the microscope, again

June 20, 2023

Two members of Brooke-Alvinston council are under the microscope for their ties to a local service club.

It’s the second time complaints have been launched against council members who also serve with the Alvinston Optimist Club.

In Jan. 2021, when Brooke-Alvinston decided to build a pavilion at the Brooke-Alvinston-Inwood Community Centre, the municipality went to the Integrity Commissioner with the same concerns after a public complaint. Now both Councillor Jenny Redick and Deputy Mayor Frank Nemcek are the subject of a complaint which Robert Swayze is again looking into. And Redick is frustrated by the move.

Redick says this complaint apparently came after council passed a contract with the Alvinston Optimist for the use of the pavilion. 

Redick and Nemcek, both Optimist members, voted in favour of the deal, as did the rest of council.

Sometime after the vote, a complaint was launched, which Clerk Janet Denkers says is now in the hands of the Integrity Commissioner. She’s not clear if a full investigation is already underway.

But Redick is confused by the action, saying this matter was deal with under the former council. 

In Dec. 2020, council moved ahead agreeing to move forward with a pavilion project from the Optimists. 

A letter, addressed to the mayor and council and included in the minutes the next meeting, questioned whether the Optimist members were in conflict over moving the project forward. Council was split on the decision.

Council reviewed it in Jan. 2021 and decided to ask Integrity Commissioner Robert Swayze to weigh in. 

By February, he responded that then Councillor Jamie Armstrong and Nemcek were able to make decision on the project.

“They are both members of the club but I understand they are volunteers and not paid as members. I also understand that neither of them is in the building business and will not benefit in any way from the construction of the building except as members of the community,” he wrote.

“In my opinion, the two members do not have a pecuniary interest in the construction of the building and therefore do not contravene the MCIA (Municipal Conflict of Interest Act.) It is not required that they declare a conflict on any related matter coming before council.”

Swayze added if they feel they can’t be impartial they could chose to declare a conflict, but that would mean their vote would be against the project. 

Redick says this appears to be virtually the same situation since the rental agreement would see money returned to the municipality, not the councillors.

“I went back and looked, the Integrity Commissioner at the time found no pecuniary interest, because there was no exchange of money. I wasn’t benefiting it from it, neither was my family,” she tells The Independent. “I just find it’s a real shame that it has to happen again.

“With small municipalities that don’t have the bodies to go around to do good things for our community, and you rely on user groups and volunteers; if we didn’t have the volunteers and the user groups that we have, we would be like a ghost town.”

Redick adds politics attracts the same type of community-minded people as those who join service clubs.

“We want better the community; that’s why I went on council I want to better my community. That’s why I joined the Optimist because they do so much for the municipality.”

Share This

Image
Front Page

LCCVI, North Lambton bow out in Lambton-Kent boys volleyball finals

November 12, 2026

John Wright/The Independent John McGregor took down both Lambton County ‘AA’ schools in the LKSSAA boys volleyball finals Wednesday in Chatham. The Panthers beat North Lambton 25-20, 25-18, and 25-20 in the junior final. The match was the Eagles first appearance in a Lambton-Kent ‘AA’ championship game since moving up to the division last season. John McGregor defeated LCCVI 25-15,

Read More

Image
Front Page

Wyoming Lions make over $90K in donations to local health care

November 11, 2026

The Independent The Wyoming Lion and Lioness Clubs donated $93,000 to the renovations at Charlotte Eleanor Englehart Hospital and the expansion of St. Joseph’s Hospice at Lambton Meadowview Villa. Tuesday night, the clubs donated $43,203 to St. Joseph’s Hospice. Lions and Lioness Presidents Paul Hendrick and Vicki Ducharme, presented the cheque to Kelly Chartrand, executive director, and Tammy Witcher, special

Read More

Image
Front Page

Students mark Remembrance Day in Alvinston

November 11, 2026

Heather Wright/The Independent Students, staff, parents, siblings and members of the Alvinston Legion took time to remember with the students at Brooke Central School. Students created class wreaths to lay at the cross in gymnasium, sang in Flanders Field and observed a moment of silence with members of the Legion after the community’s ceremony at the cenotaph.

Read More

Image
Front Page

Community gathers in Watford for Remembrance Day

November 11, 2026

Blake Ellis/The Independent People in Warwick Township joined the rest of the nation at the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month to remember those who served our nation in the military. Hundreds gathered in Watford for the Act of Remembrance led by the Watford Legion members.

Read More