Image

March 17, 2017

 

The owner of Sunnyside Manor says he’s likely to appeal any move to have the house designated under the Ontario Heritage Act.

And David Burnie says the Town of Petrolia’s process to approve his minor variance has been “a violation of the constitution.”

Burnie was in council chambers Monday as councillors examined three options for the property widely known as Fairbank House. Burnie wants to build a 16-unit apartment building on the property. However there is widespread opposition to the move.

The application to allow two buildings on one property was approved, however it is now being appealed to the Ontario Municipal Board.

So March 1, Burnie gave the town three options, he says to “try to come up with a solution.”

Burnie suggested he would continue with the renovations on the house and put an addition on the home – leaving one building on the property and “given the family’s past commitment to the home, a clear statement of trust in rebuilding the house without restoration.”

Burnie also suggested the lot be severed to allow the apartment building to go up.

He also offered to sell the property to the town for over $5 million.

After less than a 10 minute discussion, town council agreed the best of the options would be to allow an addition on the current building.

But Councillors Liz Welsh and Ross O’Hara made it clear the move to declare the building historic under the Ontario Heritage Act would continue.

At the end of meeting, when the public had a chance to speak to council, Burnie went to the podium and unleashed on council saying he is opposed to anyone’s property being designated against their will adding “The whole process is a violation of the constitution… It guarantees the life, liberty and security of a person… the right not to be deprived of fundamental justice… and the state of being exempt from domination of another – the heritage designation is the domination of others,” says Burnie likening the process to Bolshevik times.

He says the public notion that the house would disappear under his watch is “nonsense.” He says Charles O. Fairbank told his father, while he stood by, that he would have torn the building down if he couldn’t find a buyer.

“The actions of the Burnie family has kept this home on the property… and an apartment building on the site would not jeopardize the house at all.

“Over the past 50 years, everything has not gone like a fairy tale but it is standing because of one group and one group only. I’m just asking for a little grace and humanity.”

Councillor Grant Purdy countered; “I saw the smirks on your face and the disdain for this process… your sincerity and your word are very hard to accept.”

After the meeting, Burnie told The Independent the legal wranglings have likely pushed the project back two years. He has yet to decide if he will defend his position at the OMB or move ahead with the restoration of the home. But he added it was “likely” he would appeal the heritage designation if it moves forward.

Share This

Image
Front Page

Crocheting senior of the year

July 14, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent When she was in her 30s, a neighbour offered to teach Ruth Anne Mater to crochet. It looked fun, so she picked up a hook. It seems to many as though her hands have not been idle since. Monday, Mater was honoured as Dawn-Euphemia’s Senior of the Year. Mayor Al Broad says Mater “has been a quiet

Read More

Image
Front Page

Wyoming’s Jackson taken by Yankees in MLB Draft

July 14, 2025

The Independent Core Jackson may be headed to the Big Apple. The Wyoming native was selected in the fifth round of the MLB Draft by the New York Yankees on Monday afternoon. Jackson has played college baseball at the University of Utah for the past two years. He slashed .364/.445/.641 with 12 home runs, 44 RBI, and 20 stolen bases

Read More

Image
Front Page

Information and Privacy Commissioner orders Petrolia to release 2021 letter from mayor banning town councillor

July 14, 2025

Heather Wright/The Independent Nearly four years, after Petrolia Mayor Brad Loosley banned a councillor from attending in camera meetings, the town has been forced to release the letter spelling out his reasons. In June 2022, while investigating a Code of Conduct complain against the mayor for the release of confidential information to The Independent, the investigator found Loosley had banned

Read More

Image
Front Page

Flyers sign veterans, Flags go with youth

July 13, 2025

Barry Wright/The Independent The Petrolia Flyers have reached into east Lambton for a pair of players for the coming season. Alvinston’s Joey Hayter and Ty Moffatt of Watford are both joining the PJHL team. Hayter, 19, has played the past two seasons with the Blenheim Blades including scoring 15 goals and adding 31 assists in 51 regular season and playoff

Read More